We love cheese – plain and simple.

With farmer owners and Amish roots, at the Heritage Ridge Creamery we are dedicated to crafting traditional cheeses with quality at the forefront.

Read Our Story

Our Products

Taste for yourself our award winning cheeses and butter delivered right to your door

Meet Our Farmers

Get to know our farmers and find out more about what goes into making our famous award winning cheeses.

Get to Know Our Farmers

Plan a Visit

The only place in Indiana’s Amish country where you can come to see championship cheese being made!

When visiting our Middlebury facility, you will have the opportunity to view the make process of our world champion Colby (along with our other cheeses), sample a cheese offered in our store, and shop for your favorite local Amish goods.

Plan Your Visit Today »